Laughably false image. The zionist entity tank would NOT stop. The American tank would NOT stop. The British tank would NOT stop. The German tank would NOT stop.
And nearly all of them would say the protestor was a terrorist and justify it would say they were antisemitic and deserved it, would slander their character in death and use it to justify a crackdown on speech because they want to prevent more people acting like that.
The zionist entity tank would NOT stop. The American tank would NOT stop. The British tank would NOT stop. The German tank would NOT stop.
The problem is that Westerners were and are to assume that Tank Man got squished, despite the photographic & video evidence to the contrary. It was an exemplary work of propaganda, and I’m pretty sure most people ate that onion whole.
Sneaky communists, always carrying out their atrocities off screen
Not that minute, but he could easily have been one of the several thousand who died that were squshed and washed down the drains.
It must be so easy being an anti-communist; you can just make up what ever bullshit you like and expect people to believe you. Even when what you’re saying is straight up impossible because human biology doesn’t work that way
Photos were linked elsewhere. I’m making no political statements (if you like, I’ll state that the west has enabled massacres far worse than Tiananmen Square). I’m just ensuring history isn’t whitewashed.
You’re ensuring that the US military-intelligece-propaganda-industrial complex’s false narrative is maintained. You’re doing the global hegemon’s work for free, unaware that you’d been propagandized by them like everyone else. Including almost all of us. Most of us used to be just as hoodwinked as anyone.
The exact opposite. Tiananmen square massacre is not global. It is not US. It is only China trying to whitewash it’s history.
Carry on, brave protector of truth, justice, freedom, and democracy. Don’t forget to post an ”on this day in 1989, nothing happened“ meme next June.
He could much more easily not have. And (1) several thousand people didn’t die, 200–300 did, and (2) there is zero evidence that anyone at all got squished by a tank.
Yeah, “other sources“ are the CIA, the CIA cut-out NED, Radio Free Asia, etc.
Have you not figured out yet that the only reason there was any violence in the first place is that the United States organized, trained, and funded the people who brought the violence? That Dr. Gene “color revolution” Sharp and his team were in Beijing when this all happened? This was yet another attempt at a “color revolution” by the US, in a long line of regime change shenanigans by the world’s premier imperialist, terrorist state. And on top of that, they’ve convinced us to blame China for it all.
Where do you think the Salafi Jihadi terrorists in Xinjiang suddenly appeared from? From the same US regime change playbook as ever. Where do you think the Salafi jihadi terrorists-cum-“moderate rebels” that just took over Syria came from? Or Osama bin Laden?
The CIA has a dark history of dirty tricks, but this is the first time I’ve heard them being blamed for the Tiananmen Square massacre.
But I do recognise your concern. The US ambassador quoted deaths in the 10,000s. Certainly not credible.
this is the first time I’ve heard them being blamed for the Tiananmen Square massacre.
Well you’re not going to hear it in corporate journalism, in US- & capitalist-funded NGOs, or in corporate social media. The books on it aren’t going to show up on the NYT bestseller list or at airport bookstores or Barnes & Noble. They’re written by scholars/historians/researchers who know they probably won’t break even for the effort, if they manage to get published at all. Nor will you hear it from “neutral point of view” Wikipedia. I already covered this stuff upthread. You really have to go out of your way, which few have the time or energy for, and anyway almost no one would have a reason to question what they take to be bipartisan “common knowledge” in the first place.
Please check if this is possible. I beg you. You have a shirt of some trousers or something that’s too worn to wear or donate. Go put it outside and drive over it with your car over and over. Does it ever liquefy? You can put cloth on tramlines and they still wouldn’t ‘wash down the drain’.
And the tank man video is him stopping the tanks from leaving, not arriving. He’s telling the soldiers to turn around and ‘finish the job’.
You can see the square in the background of the video, there’s just rows of bicycles.
The whole “all the protesters were herded into the square, machine gunned, then homoginized via tank and washed down a drain” is a fabrication.
What actually happened, you can look up the gorey pictures and everything: Protestor groups 1-2 blocks away from the square lynch multiple cops, burning the bodies. Cops proceeded to drive around shooting civilians 1-2 blocks away from the square. Multiple police trucks end up burned in the surrounding streets, its unclear whether they were killing people mostly at random or entirely at random.
Your version is suspicious lacking student deaths. It is inconsistent with these NSFL photos.
Student deaths are included in the protestor deaths.
The brief summery is entirely consistent with those images, every image of casualties we can see are in the surrounding streets and not the square, there is no images of tanks and streets covered in gore, and the number of corpses we see are in the dozens, not tens of thousands, which is more consistent with the claims of 1-300 dead.
You didn’t talk about protester or student deaths. You only focused on the poor poor soldiers.
Dont be pedantic. The protests focal point was the square. Protesters being murdered in nearly streets don’t need a separately named massacre.
there is no images of tanks and streets covered in gore
There are dead bodies mangled with crushed bicycles. And the photos are of streets covered in gore.
the number of corpses we see are in the dozens
So the only proof you will only accept is photo of every death? Fuck off you Sealion.
The point was the story we’re all told about tanks squishing thousands of protesters because those commies just hate freedom is entirely orthogonal to actual events. And no, describing police driving around murdering people either mostly at random or entirely at random is not trying to make you feel sorry for the police. I get the sense that you aren’t talking to me, but this weird idea of what a tankie is that only exists in your head.
There are dead bodies mangled with crushed bicycles
The images aren’t easy to look at, but theres bodies that were shot by the cops while riding their bicycles, but no piles of gore mixed with crushed bicycle.
So the only proof you will only accept is photo of every death?
You haven’t offered any proof for thousands being dead though.
In which atrocity of usa did that projection actually happen?
rant
That’s what I hate about so many western people who even in beginning to question the propaganda of today repeat yesterday’s thoughtlessly. How they never stopping to consider how in the west they murder people all the time openly. They kneel on people’s necks, they choke them out, they do no-knocks and shoot people dead. Leadership of police accountability organizations like BLM wind up dying in statistically suspicious numbers in traffic accidents and similar. They assassinate MLK and Fred Hampton, they bomb residential buildings, they shoot unarmed college students. Yet a picture of a tank refusing to run over a guy is not only proof of how evil and callous a certain other country was in 1989 but a reason to continue repeating the image. An image motif pushed deliberately by the spy agencies and military psyops and dishonest genocide abetting press of the countries in the image so that we don’t say adopt an image of American atrocities which don’t end with the guy walking off but with them a splatter on the pavement or financially ruined and in jail. So that even in criticizing these countries, you uphold their narratives in the motif of the image you chose which is to slander another nation and helpfully deflect some people into thinking things like “at least we’re not that other country yet, bad as we are, they’re badder”. Even in criticizing them you do their dirty work by using their tools, their narrative, their framing.
People not only don’t know what’s happening to them, they don’t even know that they don’t know.
Try to tell them and,
Sounds like wherever you live needs a good old invasion and some colonialism. That’ll get you thinking right!
Would stop, but only to avoid creating a martyr.
not at all. first of all the IOF kill people for sport. literally maiming children deliberately as a game, for fun. if they worried about martyrs they would at least hesitate to kill aid workers from other countries. they don’t care because they’re not people. they’re demons.
Israel’s tank doesn’t stop. Just ask Rachel Corrie
I get the intent here, but Tank Man as a symbol of defiance against tyranny is a product of US ant-China/anti-communist propaganda. Previously:
It may surprise you to learn that tank man was standing in the way of tanks leaving the square and going back to base. After climbing on to the tank and talking with the crew, he eventually left the area with some other civilians.
Video of exactly that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qq8zFLIftGk- The Tian’anmen Square ‘Massacre’: The West’s Most Persuasive, Most Pervasive Lie.
- Columbia Journalism Review: The Myth of Tiananmen
- 1989 Tian’anmen Square riots
- A Note on the Tiananmen Protests
- Images from Tiananmen 1989 the West never shows (NSFW / CW: violence and death)
- How psy-ops warriors fooled me about Tiananmen Square: a warning
… Tank Man as a symbol of defiance against tyranny is a product of US ant-China/anti-communist propaganda.
I hate ant-China! You can never get the bowls clean enough and the plates barely hold anything.
China isn’t communist, your sources aren’t reliable, and they were tyrants on that day.
The PRC is in the primary stage of socialism. The large firms and key industries are state owned, while there is diverse ownership of medium and small firms such as cooperative, private, and joint-stock. It has not reached communism:
As for the June 4th incident, it was a tragedy. Legitimate greivances were hijacked by CIA-backed protest leaders that admitted to wanting to spark a massacre, then when the PRC showed restraint for a month some of the protestors started lynching unarmed PLA officers and burning them alive in vehicles by firebombing them. This sparked the state response, which was an immense tragedy, but at the same time this was an entirely avoidable outcome that only really happened because the west took advantage of a protest and changed it from being a Maoist protest into a liberal one begging for colonization from the US.
To this day, despite records stating that around 1-300 people died, the west still claims 10,000 were killed based on a falsified British cable.
Right… the video and photos are fakes and Columbia Journalism Review is a conspiracy rag 🙄
You Are Not Immune To Propaganda
Previously on c/asklemmy: What are some good places to start getting acquainted with American politics in as unbiased a manner as possible?
The first step is to understand the media, which Media Bias/Fact Check and the Ad Fontes Media* are never going to teach you. The only people who are taught it are those who get degrees in marketing, public relations, political science, history, and journalism; and even then only some of them.
The new post-Trump/“post-truth” media literacy curricula won’t teach it to you either, because it was paid for and crafted by the US military-industrial complex: New Media Literacy Standards Aim to Combat ‘Truth Decay’.
This week, the RAND Corporation released a new set of media literacy standards designed to support schools in this task.
The standards are part of RAND’s ongoing project on “truth decay”: a phenomenon that RAND researchers describe as “the diminishing role that facts, data, and analysis play in our political and civic discourse.”
None of it is a secret, though, and it can be learned.
- Noam Chomsky - The 5 Filters of the Mass Media Machine
- Propaganda model
- Edward Bernays
- Walter Lippmann
- Council on Foreign Relations
- Powell Memorandum
- The Trilateral Commission’s report, The Crisis of Democracy
*I’ve criticized MBFC & Ad Fontes before:
The videos and photos are very much real, but they do not leave any evidence for your titles or descriptions of them.
The article of the Columbia Journalism Review does not argue that the Chinese government did not massacre people as a result of pro-democracy demonstrations. It just argues it didn’t happen literally at the square.
You might be the one absorbing and repeating propaganda here.
You might be the one absorbing and repeating propaganda here.
Golly, after all these years of investigating and talking with people, that thought had never occurred to me. You‘ve opened my eyes to new possibilities.
The cia massacred people. The legitimate demonstrations were hijacked by colonialist cia agents who wanted to enslave all of china to the usa.
You seem to focus entirely on English-language American propaganda. Did you ever apply that to yourself and wonder if you’ve absorbed any Chinese propaganda?
I focus on Five Eyes propaganda because I live there and speak English. It’s the propaganda that I’ve lived under my entire life, and it’s the propaganda that’s targeted specifically at me, my peers, and my community.
China is on the other side of the world, and I can’t read or speak Chinese. I’m hardly affected by China’s media, and I can only significantly affect my own community, not ones that are oceans away.
You’re on the internet, on social media, which is accessed by people from around the world, and Chinese people can speak English. People from outside our own community can and do try to manipulate us using propaganda.
Wow, yet more wisdom revealed to me for the first time. Where have you been all my life?
Its gonna be hard to absorb if you can’t read chinese
Tyrants were heroes who freed the people from evil monarchs. The establishment (evil monarchs’ buddies) hated tyrants so much they wrote all sorts of “tyrants bad” stories.
Your “West never shows” images are missing some dead students (NSFL obviously)
China claimed from the beginning that around 200 people died in the conflict that day (including PLA soldiers).
My point was that those linked photos showed no dead students.
the tanks were leaving the square, is this guy blocking the tanks leaving?
👆 If only I had the concision to deliver it so deftly.
broken keyboard incentivizes brevity
slow clap
Not only were they leaving the square, they were never again deployed at any point throughout the month of June 1989, and a package of democratic reforms was quickly passed and the protesters all were free to go about their daily lives. That guy was just silly and confused, there was nothing to be concerned about and definitely no reason to think tanks which had just fired on civilians would be doing anything else bad such as being redeployed and continuing to enforce martial law.
prove it or delete your account in shame
0.0002% of the time it, works every time https://lemmy.ml/comment/10247122
we gotta pump those numbers up
tanks which had just fired on civilians
Can you please explain
A) Why there was no blood on or around the tanks as they left the square, when the popular story is that they were running people over, and
B) Why the tank crews, who had supposedly been killing people right up until that moment, all just simultaneously decided not to kill one more who was in their way?
and definitely no reason to think tanks which had just fired on civilians
There is literally zero evidence, and there is contrary evidence from several Western journalists who were on the scene that day. You’ve been duped; virtually all of us were.
tanks which had just fired on civilians
It must be so easy being an anti communist, you can just make up whatever baseless bullshit you like and expect people to believe you
Your sarcasm edit doesn’t make you sound more clever, just more vague.
and the protesters all were free to go about their daily lives.
The Tiananmen Square Massacre Never Happened (Reupload pt1) (Reupload pt2) (Reupload pt3)
The students keep asking, ”What should we do next? What can we accomplish?” I feel so sad, because how can I tell them that what we are actually hoping for is bloodshed, for the moment when the government has no choice but to brazenly butcher the people. Only when the square is awash with blood will the people of China open their eyes. Only then will they really be united. But how can I explain any of this to my fellow students? And what is truly sad is that some students and some well-connected people are working hard to help the government to prevent it from taking such measures.
— CIA asset Chai Ling, one of the terrorists evacuated in Operation Yellowbird by the CIA, MI6, and Chinese triad goons
I love not thinking!
Personally I don’t think this is an effective image as in the tankman incident this is presumably base on, the tankers showed far more restraint than the IOF is capable of, and the guy was able to climb on the tank and run away with no consequences: https://youtu.be/FaojdRThXbY
A better example maybe one of these incidents(out of many others) of US state forces running over protestors in the last couple of years:
There were rumors that he was executed but that can’t be right.
don’t you have some pics of what are clearly bicycles left abandoned to post while masturbating and crying gnashing wailing tears over how they’re bodies or something
I don’t have any room left on my hard drive, which is full of pictures of monuments to tank man that were constructed all over China to celebrate him as a civil rights icon who definitely wasn’t executed.
The CIA executed him? The same way cia murdered civilians that day (by burning them to death)? Horrible monsters. Luckily, in 2012, china enacted justice on many cia agents.
Woah sick burn!
Vague, sarcastic smugassery is not a substitute for evidence.
This is just you going “I assume they executed him, because that’s what those yellow savages do over there”.
Good job, definitely nothing racist about that.
Why not execute him right then and there?
anything referencing Tiananmen Square
dozens of comments
What are we, a bunch of Asians?
Those tanks refer to regimes and governments, not the people, there are good people and bad people everywhere in every country.
This “blame the government not the people” schtick has got to go…
This thinking is just an attempt to resolve a cognitive dissonance or something. Basically, it ends up looking like you coyly address the issue without trying to anger anyone, which ends up watering down the whole point…
Fuck it, just say “Fuck America” because Fuck America, “Fuck the EU” because fuck the EU and I don’t only mean the countries within the union and “Fuck the Commonwealth” because fuck the Commonwealth. No punch pullsies. And no hiding behind a palatable Tank Man for Westoids to reinforce their biases, even in good meaning.
Not enough Arab autocracies in line there. Egypt and Saudi get much less hate about their role in the genocide than they deserve.
Those arab countries was bough by the usa to support israel. Still not excusing their complicities
Can’t buy what’s not for sale.
I remember this image was at the top of the controversial sort.
But America is the only country that still supports Israel.
How are you getting upvoted? Pretty much every one of the US’s vassal states in europe is supporting Israel with weaponry.
This is getting ridiculous. Is there nothing you’re not wrong about? Has it occurred to you that what a state publicly says and what that state’s stance on the matter might actually be is not always the same?
Well that’s just obviously not true
False
deleted by creator
I don’t like this.
It portrays a false consensus for Israel. The opposite is true.
How many countries lied about stop sending weapons. How many still talk about israel right to defense. How many still refuse palestinians tight to resistsace and a military?
Fewer than 30
