• Rednax@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        21
        ·
        11 days ago

        My group tried Shadowrun, but we kept falling asleep. Counting dozens of dice for every fart you do was just too relaxing for us.

        • Ooops@feddit.org
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          14
          ·
          11 days ago

          You just need to know how to use a marker and then you throw two handful fo dice and can see the successes instantly…

            • Ooops@feddit.org
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              10 days ago

              Just the successes. And up to around one handful is what basically everyone can grasp with just one look.

              And the 1s are only relevant if they make up more than half of all roles and there are no successes. Which doesn’t happen with more than a few dice.

        • skulblaka@sh.itjust.works
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          10 days ago

          Honestly I think the dice are both the high and low point of Shadowrun. At low to mid level, when everything that happens requires 6-15 d6, it can drag a little bit.

          Counterpoint, once you have your build running, sniping a guy in the head from three blocks away for 162d6 damage is very empowering. Or being able to cleave a man square from head to asshole right through his dermal plating with a vibro katana.

          But by and large though SR is loved for its setting more than for its mechanics. Cyberpunk is probably just generally a better TTRPG, no matter how much of a sordid love affair I have with SR.

        • captainlezbian@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          10 days ago

          I’d love a shadowrun style setting with 5e or pf2 style rules. Even if I wouldn’t be able to find anyone to play it

      • Moah@lemmy.blahaj.zone
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        9
        ·
        11 days ago

        Funny story, they added magic and dragon to shadowrun because cyberpunk released first, and they knew they were cooked without a USP.

      • the_weez@midwest.social
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        8
        ·
        11 days ago

        I mean hacking is basically like magic and nothing stops you from making a cyber dragon or robo dragon or whatever.

      • sbv@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        8
        ·
        11 days ago

        I picked up Cyberpunk when RED came out. Mostly because my table was into it. Compare to the lore and flavour of Shadowrun, it feels anemic.

      • Cethin@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        10 days ago

        Cyberpunk has magic. They just call it things like “ice”, or “virus”, or whatever, and use some technobable to explain why it technically isn’t actually magic.

    • cruseo@piefed.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      10 days ago

      I finally bought it this summer when it went on sale, and I already am on my 7th playthrough. I think I’m somewhere around 750 hrs of playtime already.

      Edit: oof, that’s a lot for 3 1/2 months

  • hperrin@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    57
    ·
    11 days ago

    I had a friend’s son come to me asking to learn to program so he could make video games. I started teaching him C#, and he thought it was too hard. He said he just wants to learn to make Roblox mods. It was very disappointing.

    • endless_nameless@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      74
      ·
      11 days ago

      I used to teach programming to young kids (like 8-12) as a summer job and never had a single kid complain about the difficulty or fail to learn. This was about a decade ago.

      I recently tried teaching my cousin (9) using the same curriculum and it was nearly impossible. He didn’t know how to turn his computer on or off and he didn’t know what a file was or what “text” means. I basically had to root his Chromebook to install a competent text editor on it. Then every time the “computer” booted it said something like “press G to revert” in huge text for like a minute straight and I told him never to press it. Took like 2 hours to put the computer in a state where you could code on it, and next session after that it was reset. I was like “what happened to the computer?” and he said “it said to press G so I did”

      Kids are fucked bro. I blame Google, Apple, and Microsoft for intentionally designing their software to prevent you from learning how computers work or how to use them. They don’t want you developing any transferrable skills whatsoever. You used to learn all about computers just by using them and it was impossible not to…

      • madmantis24@lemmy.wtf
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        10 days ago

        This has been a thorn in my side at least as far back as Windows 8, and the LLM craze has only thrown jet fuel on the damn fire

        EDIT: I don’t have to deal with kids that much but I’ve noticed that it’s wrapped around to affecting older adults and that’s maybe worse since they’re the same generation as the politicians making decisions for all of us involving technology

      • RaphaelSchmitz@feddit.org
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        10 days ago

        OK that “press G” prompt is horrible, though.

        We know the younger generations are somewhat cooked, and that, wouldn’t trust a boomer or GenXer with that either. Even for a millennial that’s horrible UX.

        • endless_nameless@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          9 days ago

          It’s designed to trick people. It displays the message for 30 seconds or a full minute (don’t remember) every single time it boots. There is no indication that there is a timer running. If there’s a way to skip it and/or disable it, it isn’t not apparent.

          Ok get this: Putting the computer into a state where it will so graciously allow you to install a text editor also requires completely wiping all data on it. Good thing my cousin didn’t know that you could even save data to a computer in the first place! Pressing G to revert it also completely wipes it. Imagine working on something for a week before pushing it to some remote git repo and accidentally hitting that.

          They are completely, intentionally fucking up the minds of children to make them dependent for life. We need a new round of Nuremberg trials for big tech.

    • pet the cat, walk the dog@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      11 days ago

      I mean, people have different paths of entry into programming, lots of them started by making mods for their favorite game. And Lua is a great lightning-fast language with minimal footprint, excellent for interactive use-cases, that folks keep dismissing for no good reason.

      • hperrin@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        9
        ·
        10 days ago

        It was more that he just wanted something easy. He didn’t want to work for it. He thought that making Roblox mods would mean he didn’t need to learn to program.

        • pet the cat, walk the dog@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          9 days ago

          I wonder if there’s some kinda visual environment, maybe in the vein of Scratch, that would trick him into learning programming while not feeling that way. That’s often the approach that one must take not only with children, but even in adulthood when the full-blown subject feels too much for one’s bandwidth.

        • MonkeMischief@lemmy.today
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          10 days ago

          That’s so sad. I feel like (perhaps pre-Microslop) Minecraft modding or Gmod scripting would teach people to code too, but Roblox is just so damn predatory.

          It runs off the free labor of children hoping to make money. I feel like few people are going to learn to code and enjoy it with that kinda motive.

          I noticed people would build skills so fast when it was about doing fun stuff to share with friends or a community because they thought it would be cool.

    • Kichae@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      11 days ago

      There’s a whole game studio here that just makes games and mods for Roblox. It really is kind of the example in the OP.

  • justdaveisfine@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    38
    ·
    11 days ago

    This is definitely something I’ve been frustrated about more so over time. I have a bunch of game books sitting on my shelf just ready to play as soon as I can convince my players that there is something more.

    • naught101@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      25
      ·
      11 days ago

      He’s a strategy: get a copy of Microscope by Ben Robbins, and tell them you’re going to use it to create the world/setting for your next campaign (this is something many people do). Once they’ve played, ask them to do a stars and wishes, see what they say (I would be extremely surprised if they don’t love it).

      Then point out that Microscope is a ttrpg, just a wildly different one to D&D, and that there are thousands of other games that do weird and interesting things with mechanics that most trad games can’t even dream of doing (e.g. some examples: Everyone is John, Ten Candles, Fiasco, Wanderhome, We Are But Worms).

      Viditya Voleti’s A Land Once Magic is another good option that you can do this with, and it’s a bit quicker and easier than Microscope.

      • subverted_per@lemmy.blahaj.zone
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        8
        ·
        11 days ago

        I have never managed to get a group to finish a WoD campaign. Most dont last more than a couple sessions. And i can’t even get started on Legend of the Five Rings. Or Star Trek d6.

        • jtrek@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          10 days ago

          Back in like 2016 I got a game of vampire going. I pitched it to two non-ttrpg friends as “what if you’re vampires but the head vampire in the city is basically Donald Trump…”. 100% player retention.

          Game ran for like two years. Lots of blood. We still talk about how the highlights.

  • straussbelial@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    32
    ·
    10 days ago

    —Do you like TV series?

    —You mean like Games of Thrones?

    —Yeah, or any other

    —I watched the first season some years ago

    —And have you watched any other than GoT?

    —What do you mean

    —IDK, like Breaking Bad

    —That’s like a more crime centered GoT right?

    —No, it’s a different one, is not fantasy

    —Mmm but it’s still about dragons and stuff, right?

    —No, it has nothing to do with GoT, it takes place in current USA actually

    —Ok, well I guess people try to adapt magic and fantasy armies to anything now

    —No, it’s not about fantas…

    —I think I’ll stick to the original one

    —Ok 😒

  • its_kim_love@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    29
    ·
    11 days ago

    I just want to go back to the time it was considered rude to play at a table more than a month or two without cracking the book and learning the rules on your own time.

        • crunchy@lemmy.dbzer0.com
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          9
          ·
          10 days ago

          I like in-universe explanations and using game mechanics that support my character choices. For example, say I’m building a rogue character that’s an experienced assassin, but why would they still be at level 1, or even 3? Maybe they’ve never actually killed anyone but they’re very good at “disappearing” people with poisons and potions, so they’d take medicine and/or nature as a skill. So maybe now we have an “assassin” that secretly helps people flee town by faking their deaths and I see what can be done with potions, herbs, medicines, magic, etc.

    • apotheotic (she/her)@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      10 days ago

      God, it might just be the autism, but before my first ever session I learned so much about the rules I was helping the gm remember them in the session. I can’t imagine going in to it, much less continuing to play, without having a firm grasp of at least the basic rules of encounters and skill checks

  • mad_lentil@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    23
    ·
    10 days ago

    Having played several systems I have no idea why anyone chooses d&d other than it seems like the default.

    I’m in a d&d group and every time they’re flipping through the books I want to shake them and show them literally anything else. Even just vibe up your own system on the spot.

    • uberfreeza@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      10
      ·
      10 days ago

      Im pretty sure that’s the reason why. My group started on d&d because it’s the default and so has a lot of resources available starting out for players and gms alike. We don’t do d&d anymore and migrated to other systems after ending the campaign.

      • mad_lentil@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        9 days ago

        That’s cool, but also I feel I was a little judgy in my comment. If anyone just straight up enjoys d&d for what it is there’s nothing wrong with that.

  • definitelycodex@ttrpg.network
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    10 days ago

    I can’t even begin to understand why people prefer D&D 5e when PF2e covers the exact same niche but with more well rounded rules, tighter math, way more character options and at a lower price.

    Like, it’s not even a matter of preference. You can literally play the same types of games as D&D, but better.

    I don’t understand people

  • Sir_Thominick_IV@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    15
    ·
    11 days ago

    Shoutout to Death in Space for being my primary TTRPG going forward.

    I want space ships and lovecraftian horrors that lurk between the stars. And I love that it treats the party’s ship/space station as a shared character.

    • Barbarian@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      11 days ago

      Only War had the party’s imperial guard regiment as a full on ‘character’ that they made together, complete with stats and traits. Really cool system.

  • Zizzy@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    14
    ·
    10 days ago

    idk i think its a bad analogy. Its more like calling all rts games starcraft or something. They can be thematically different and even play very differently but the underlying structure is the same. And its not unreasonable when talking with someone who isnt knowledgable to start with something similar and if they care to hear more to explain the differences and if they dont then the conversation can end

      • 5318008@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        10 days ago

        I thought the defining feature of “Souls-like” games was more about the difficulty of said hacking and slashing, and heavy punishment for mistakes.

        • moakley@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          6
          ·
          10 days ago

          But it also has to have tight controls. Failure has to be the player’s fault. That’s the defining characteristic.

          • jtrek@startrek.website
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            10 days ago

            Failure has to be the player’s fault.

            I was going to say “they have to have low random factors” but I realized that’s the same thing. Dying to a random crit in a souls-like would be infuriating

  • yermaw@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    14
    ·
    10 days ago

    Thought it was going somewhere else in the first few sentences. For a long time home-console video games were called Mario’s

  • classic@fedia.io
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    14
    ·
    11 days ago

    Yeah, I want Skyrim, but superheroes, but not Marvel and not DC. Just build your own superheroes like city of heroes had.

    Alsoholyhit, BG3, but superheroes

  • ComicalMayhem@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    10 days ago

    I managed to get a couple of my friends to try out PF2e and one doesn’t really like it so far. I keep trying to get another friend to try it but he keeps saying he doesn’t want to learn another system :(

  • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    edit-2
    10 days ago

    DnD is more like Minecraft in that it lays out a nice set of general mechanics that can be tweaked into whatever setting you want. Most ttrpgs I’ve seen don’t play all that differently from DnD

    EDIT: it seems like a bunch of people have had weak experiences with DnD because either they or their DMs are not that creative or don’t like roleplaying.

    DnD isn’t the only ttrpg. DnD isn’t necessarily the best ttrpg. But it is a great framework and there’s a reason why a lot of other ttrpg’s copy from it.

    Also yall aren’t considering that sometimes people just want to get to the part of telling the story they want to tell without having to learn a whole new system.

    • ReCursing@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      13
      ·
      11 days ago

      It’s like minecraft in that it’s hellishly ugly. And yeah, lots of rpgs play very differently than dnd. Or minecraft

    • thinkingofyouihaveananxietydisorder@quokk.au
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      edit-2
      10 days ago

      d&d is kind of shit for almost everything. its only good for a narrow pulpy sword and sorcery adventure that asks no interesting questions.

      and bitd/fitd is much better faster more adaptable for basically any pulp trash with like 5% adaptation.

      d&d is unusable for intrigue or investigation that isn’t fully railroad. the concept of the individual is so central, a player representing anything else is basically unplayable. there’s almost no consideration for the theatrical or collaborative writing elements of the genre.

      you just haven’t played any interesting ttrpg’s. you should!

      • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        10 days ago

        its only good for a narrow pulpy sword and sorcery adventure that asks no interesting questions.

        d&d is unusable for intrigue or investigation that isn’t fully railroad.

        Dude you just have had shitty DMs

        • thinkingofyouihaveananxietydisorder@quokk.au
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          10 days ago

          I said only good for. you can wedge other shit in but its absolutely not the right tool. ‘roll to search’ ‘roll to spot a tail’ ‘roll to know if he’s lying’ is not interesting.

          systems that are actually good for this shit exist.

          • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            10 days ago

            The stranger says you can trust him with the money

            Player: I want to roll insight

            (dm hidden roll: deception: 15)

            Insight 14 -> “you aren’t sure he’s lying, but you feel very uneasy trusting him”

            Insight 5 -> “you really can’t read his expression”

            Insight 16 -> “you aren’t totally sure, but you think he’s going to betray you”

            Insight 19 -> “yeah this guy is totally going to rip you off”

            The game not being interesting is largely a DM problem regardless of the framework you use.

    • Susaga@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      11 days ago

      I want you to look through the core rules and see how much of it you’d have to remove to reflect a non-violent, non-magical setting. And at that point, why are you still using D&D?

      • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        edit-2
        10 days ago

        EDIT actually on second thought the Arcana stat and related checks you’d either have to scrap or get creative about repurposing.

        Huh? The answer to this is actually literally zero.

        Just tell your players they can’t choose spell casting classes, make a decision on whether half-casterish classes like Ranger have spells that are magical or could be explained through nonmagical means, and tell your players to expect no combat.

        • Susaga@sh.itjust.works
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          10 days ago

          Just tell your players they can’t choose spell casting classes

          In other words, remove those classes from your game.

          To play without magic and combat, you’d need to ignore most of chapter 2 (only human); most of chapter 3 (only 3 classes get first level non-combat, non-magic features, and two are spellcasters); half of chapter 5 (no weapons or armour); half of chapter 6 (no combat feats); chapters 9, 10 and 11; and most of the appendices. I did a quick check, and you’d use less than 100 pages out of the 318 in the rulebook.

          So much for “literally zero”.

          • Kichae@wanderingadventure.party
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            10 days ago

            susaga@sh.itjust.works You know that picking and choosing which parts of the game to utilize is fairly standard practice, right? The rules are just frameworks for systematically determining outcomes that you’ve decided you don’t want to know in advance. You can choose which subset of conditions those outcomes occur under.

            Just because you paid for all of the rules doesn’t mean you’re in any way obligated to use them all. Even the parts that have the most pages dedicated to them.

            • Susaga@sh.itjust.works
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              10 days ago

              You also aren’t obligated to play D&D. You can play something else where you don’t have to ignore 70% of the game to get what you want. If you just want an action resolution system, play Kids On Bikes. Or Gumshoe. Or Genesys. Or flip a coin, heads you succeed.

              If you’re going to buy a system just to ignore most of it, D&D is one of the most expensive to pick.

              • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                10 days ago

                You also can just use the rules everyone is already familiar with instead of spending the first couple sessions with everyone learning a whole new system

                • Susaga@sh.itjust.works
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  10 days ago

                  I want you to realise that most systems, including the ones I mentioned, are simpler than D&D. It will not take multiple sessions to learn the rules. For the love of god, you are spending more time arguing against learning new systems than it would take to just learn the new systems.

          • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            10 days ago

            I guess in my mind the core rules are things like the stats and how ability checks work, and I’d describe classes as something like “core content”.

            • Susaga@sh.itjust.works
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              10 days ago

              If that’s how you’re measuring it, then about half of the rules are about combat or magic. If you play D&D without that, you are playing half a game.

              • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                10 days ago

                Most of my DnD campaigns have combat maybe like 1 in 5 sessions even in a fairly vanilla DnD setting. Even though there are a lot of rules for governing combat, I don’t think it’s fair to consider them half of the game.

                I always like playing in magic settings so tbh I’ve never really played without it, but I do know some settings like Cyberpunk have magic it’s just rebranded as tech themed.

    • jtrek@startrek.website
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      10 days ago

      The mechanics aren’t especially “nice”. It has a lot of legacy jank (15 strength is what bonus?). 1d20+stuff vs target produces a flat probability, which is problematic.

      it has a lot of assumptions deeply baked into the rules. You need the adventuring day, to rewrite all the powers, or sharply limit party composition, or it falls apart.

      It’s missing or has anemic offerings for whole subsystems - social conflict, meta game currency, succeed at a cost.

      Character progression is very coarse. level up and a bunch of stuff happens at once. You can’t make a character that has a shit load of sneak attack without also getting a bunch of HP and other rogue stuff.

      The magic system is brittle and poorly defined. There’s not really an expectation or system for players to make their own spells. You pick from a list. If you want to play a game about creating your own spells, it’s going to provide little guidance. Also, most of the spells are about combat, with a handful about movement.

      You can change rules, but after a certain point you’re playing something unrecognizable as DND.

      Most ttrpgs I’ve seen don’t play all that differently from DnD

      Play more games. Even a basic traditional game like Vampire is a mind opener. No adventuring day. No levels. Social conflict. No attrition and resource management. These have a big impact on the experience.

      • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        10 days ago

        TLDR I feel like I think “Minecraft is anything you can make with any of the mods out there plus in the in-game tools and your own creativity” and you think “Minecraft is vanilla Minecraft played with the main goal of slaying the ender dragon”.

        It has a lot of legacy jank (15 strength is what bonus?). 1d20+stuff vs target produces a flat probability, which is problematic.

        Yeah these things are the biggest issues with DnD and related games IMO. However, rolling a D20 is a lot of fun, which makes me not want to replace it with something like 3d6.

        it has a lot of assumptions deeply baked into the rules. You need the adventuring day, to rewrite all the powers, or sharply limit party composition, or it falls apart.

        The adventuring day is a big one. TBH I’ve never seen a ttrpg without it.

        There are massive amounts of fan content for DnD out there and easy to find, if you don’t want to write your own. There are whole ttrpgs that are practically modded DnD but tweaked for a specific setting.

        I’m not sure what you mean about limiting party composition.

        It’s missing or has anemic offerings for whole subsystems - social conflict, meta game currency, succeed at a cost.

        Hard disagree on social conflict. DnD is full of mechanics for that. Meta game currency is something DMs usually add in from my experience, although DnD does have inspiration points as a kinda weak form. Succeed at a cost is something I usually see DMs add in, but I have seen other ttrpgs with that more baked into the rules.

        You pick from a list. If you want to play a game about creating your own spells, it’s going to provide little guidance.

        Yeah that’s fair. If you have an example of a game with a good “make your own spells” system I’m curious.

        Also, most of the spells are about combat, with a handful about movement.

        Hard, hard disagree there. Off the top of my head: prestidigitation, minor illusion, friends, zone of truth, tiny hut, message, command, good berry, that one that lets you ask god a question…

        Play more games. Even a basic traditional game like Vampire is a mind opener.

        Thanks for the rec! I’ll look into it.

        • jtrek@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          10 days ago

          However, rolling a D20 is a lot of fun, which makes me not want to replace it with something like 3d6.

          Fun is subjective, but I personally really enjoy rolling a big dice pool. 4 fire firearms, 3 for dex, 2 for equipment bonus, 4 for the fate blessing, 4 for the gun being magically perfected, 3 for aiming, that’s approximately Get Fucked dice to throw on the table.

          it has a lot of assumptions deeply baked into the rules. You need the adventuring day, to rewrite all the powers, or sharply limit party composition, or it falls apart.

          The adventuring day is a big one. TBH I’ve never seen a ttrpg without it.

          Any whitewolf rpg. Fate. Gurps. Don’t rest your head. Unknown armies. Countless indie RPGs. Many games that aren’t close relatives of D&D don’t have a central model of “you have a limited amount of resources to get through the day”.

          I recently started a game of Vampire: The Requiem. One of the guys had only played D&D before, and it kind of blew his mind that he can just do his iconic stuff whenever he wants. He was going to punch a bouncer and we were like “Why don’t you just use your mesmerize?”, and he was like “I forgot I don’t have to save that”

          There are massive amounts of fan content for DnD out there and easy to find, if you don’t want to write your own. There are whole ttrpgs that are practically modded DnD but tweaked for a specific setting.

          You can also use an actual generic system like Fate or GURPS. Both of those have a ton of fan content as well. This is not a unique strength of D&D.

          Hard disagree on social conflict. DnD is full of mechanics for that.

          Please share. From what I recall, the system is limited to something like “Roll persuasion vs a DC, and that determines how big of a favor they’ll do for you”, or similar for intimidation.

          Imagine a scenario where the players encounter a group of goons blocking the road. If they want to get in a fight, D&D has a ton of rules. Movement, to-hit and damage, armor, saves. If they want to talk through it, the rules are comparably thread-bare. There’s no social HP.

          Other systems give you more. I’m pretty sure a lot of PbtA games have social moves. There’s also Monster Hearts, which I never played because you need a particular kind of group for that one.

          Side note: because of how D&D’s stats work, you end up with a lot of characters are mechanically bad at socializing, or underperform at their prescribed roles. You have to work against the system to get some concepts. The whole idea of “multiple ability dependent” is a D&D-ism that’s just not in every system. If you want to play a wise cracking dashing axe-man in Fate, for example, you can just do that. You don’t need to worry about how you can get both strength and charisma, nor about if you can just reflavor Hexblade because you don’t really want the rest of Warlock.

          Meta game currency is something DMs usually add in from my experience, although DnD does have inspiration points as a kinda weak form. Succeed at a cost is something I usually see DMs add in, but I have seen other ttrpgs with that more baked into the rules.

          Inspiration is kind of store-brand fate points, yes. You can easily add more to it, as well as bring succeed-at-a-cost into D&D. But the argument is more about how D&D provides little.

          You pick from a list. If you want to play a game about creating your own spells, it’s going to provide little guidance. Yeah that’s fair. If you have an example of a game with a good “make your own spells” system I’m curious.

          Mage: The Awakening (2e) is the crunchy one that I know. The book provides a ton of examples, but even those are flexible. You add or lose dice based on adjusting the spell details, and potentially create a pool of fuck-up dice in exchange for more dramatic changes.

          Unknown Armies is an old classic that has “random magick” as a thing any duke can pull off.

          Fate is a generic system, so it really depends on which splatbook you’re using, or what your table decides on. One game I ran had a “choose one: slow, dangerous, expensive” model for magic. The player can’t picking “dangerous” and things got really exciting.

          Also, most of the spells are about combat, with a handful about movement. Hard, hard disagree there. Off the top of my head: prestidigitation, minor illusion, friends, zone of truth, tiny hut, message, command, good berry, that one that lets you ask god a question…

          I was curious so I’m looking at a spell list on a dnd wiki. A majority of spells are for combat, followed by spells that also have exploration uses (eg: fly, alarm), and then there’s everything else. But you can’t deny that a large chunk of the spells are explicitly about doing damage, or helping you do damage.

          I spent too long on this post. Hopefully it was worth it! “People should play more RPGs, even if just to steal stuff to port into D&D” is one of my bugbears.

          • WolfLink@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            10 days ago

            Thanks for the recs, I do plan to look into them, but I also want to point out the main reason I stick to using DnD and ttrpgs that are very similar (e.g. pathfinder) as a framework is it lets your group get right into the game instead of spending a lot of time getting used to an unfamiliar system.

            Imagine a scenario where the players encounter a group of goons blocking the road. If they want to get in a fight, D&D has a ton of rules. Movement, to-hit and damage, armor, saves. If they want to talk through it, the rules are comparably thread-bare. There’s no social HP.

            This would be mostly RP’d discussion, punctuated with rolls to represent luck and stats to represent how the character and player might differ.

            It would be something like the player asking the goons to move, the goons saying no, the player asking why, the goons giving some answer, the player rolling insight and then deciding a follow up question, probably ending with a persuasion or intimidation check with a DC dependent on how well the rest of the discussion went, with the possibility for other shenanigans to influence as well (like maybe the party mage used minor illusion to fake a badge to pretend to be cops).

            I honestly don’t think something like “social HP” would be better than RP and shenanigans, but idk, I would be curious to try.

            Side note: because of how D&D’s stats work, you end up with a lot of characters are mechanically bad at socializing, or underperform at their prescribed roles.

            This is definitely a weakness of DnD. It helps if your party is more into the RP aspects than absolutely optimizing their characters for combat. Another thing I’ve done as DM is to give players a choice, like jumping across a gap could be acrobatics or athletics, so they can use the stats they are good at.

            I was curious so I’m looking at a spell list on a dnd wiki. A majority of spells are for combat, followed by spells that also have exploration uses (eg: fly, alarm), and then there’s everything else.

            I think the issue with combat oriented spells is you have spells at each level that do “vaguely this level’s worth of damage” for every damage type so you get a nice progression curve. Out-of-combat spells are not so easily quantifiable. What is the level 4 version of minor illusion? (There are some answers to that tbh). There also are damaging spells that explicitly have non-combat purposes (one of the main ones I can think of is Phantasmal Force), as well as ones that may not explicitly say so but no DM would deny, like using fire bolt to light something on fire at a distance.

            Also I’m not sure what you have against exploration and movement type spells because those are very useful in an intrigue heavy campaign.

            Anyway, DnD does have a lot of combat mechanics, but it has plenty of non-combat mechanics too. The combat is more regimented and structured, but I don’t see that as a weakness, just the difference between combat and intrigue.

            • jtrek@startrek.website
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              10 days ago

              I also want to point out the main reason I stick to using DnD and ttrpgs that are very similar (e.g. pathfinder) as a framework is it lets your group get right into the game instead of spending a lot of time getting used to an unfamiliar system.

              That does have some value, but sunk cost is not always a great justification. Also, a lot of systems are way easier to learn than DND. I think people think it’s going to be as hard as memorizing all the DND jank - stat to bonus mappings, attack bonus by level, spell slots, a hundred different unique spells - but many systems aren’t like that. (Quick, can you Sacred Flame and object? Smite with a thrown spear?)

              I’ve been playing Vampire and the guy that’s only played DND before has had no trouble picking up the rules. Fate is maybe easier, though more creatively demanding. Lot of tyranny of the blank page potential there.

              It would be something like the player asking the goons to move, the goons saying no, the player asking why, the goons giving some answer, the player rolling insight and then deciding a follow up question, probably ending with a persuasion or intimidation check with a DC dependent on how well the rest of the discussion went, with the possibility for other shenanigans to influence as well (like maybe the party mage used minor illusion to fake a badge to pretend to be cops).

              That’s how DND would typically play it out, but some things worth noting.

              One, where armor class, saves, and HP are very codified, the DC for persuasion or intimidation is very loosey-goosey in DND.

              Fate, by contrast, has a stress track (like hit points) for physical and mental harm. So when your character pulls a knife and says “I’m gonna cut your fingers off one at a time and make you eat them”, and you roll, there’s mechanical oomph to it. You roll +7, and they’re either out of the scene of suffering a consequence. DND is just DM whims.

              I honestly don’t think something like “social HP” would be better than RP and shenanigans, but idk, I would be curious to try.

              I like how Fate does it. You’re not limited so much by your personal ability to act and the GM’s mode. You roll high on Provoke and it mechanically hits.

              Oh, another subsystem from Fate I’d recommend importing: Concede. Solves all those “omg I wiped the party” problems.

              I think the issue with combat oriented spells is you have spells at each level that do “vaguely this level’s worth of damage” for every damage type so you get a nice progression curve.

              This is almost certainly a root cause. I think you could build a neat system where you don’t have two dozen variations of “do damage” spells, but you rather have rules for how much damage and other effects can go into a spell slot. Which is kind of how Mage works, actually.

              But then casters would be having all sorts of fun and fighters would be left out again. Which, come to think of it, is a common problem in DND.

              Also I’m not sure what you have against exploration and movement type spells because those are very useful in an intrigue heavy campaign.

              Nothing against them. I just meant the majority of spells are combat.

              Anyway, DnD does have a lot of combat mechanics, but it has plenty of non-combat mechanics too. The combat is more regimented and structured, but I don’t see that as a weakness, just the difference between combat and intrigue.

              And sometimes that’s fine. But it’s not the only way for a game to be. If your game has little physical conflict and a lot of social conflict, DND is probably the wrong engine. Be like wearing a winter jacket on a summer beach trip.

              Anyway. Like I said this is one of my bugbears so I can go on. Thanks for reading

        • Raylon@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          10 days ago

          To give you another rec, which is often named as an intro to PbtA systems for dnd players: Dungeon World. It still borrows quite a few things from DnD (which are imo the worst parts of DW).

          And as the other user wrote, reading other system can even be helpful just to steal stuff for your DnD group. PbtA (or one based on it) is one that imo every GM should’ve played, because it teaches so many important principles that are relevant in any systems you play - but in PbtA they are far more explicit (and well explained in the rulebooks).

        • jtrek@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          9 days ago

          I’m not sure what you mean about limiting party composition.

          Oh I missed this earlier.

          So one solution to the pain caused by the adventuring day is to let players rest more often. But some classes get way more powerful after a long rest than others, so that’s a problem. A party of {fighter monk wizard} that gets a long rest after every fight is going to have a superstar wizard. One solution to that is only let the party consist of classes on the same rest cadence. Wizard, cleric, paladin, ranger are all long rest based. Fighter, rogue, monk, warlock are short rest.

          This causes tension even in a base line game. It’s very common for wizard players to whine about wanting a rest even when the rest of the party is good to go. You might say that’s their fault for not rationing their powers, but I’d say it’s their fault for playing a resource management game when they wanted to play a wizard game.

          Removing the adventuring day and corresponding “you need to rest to recover resources” is really difficult in DND. But people want to remove it, even if not consciously, because it sucks unless you’re aiming for a narrow range of game modes.

  • sem@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    edit-2
    10 days ago

    I don’t really understand the metaphor in the post, but i really enjoyed Dimension 20 playing Vampire the Masquerade.

    I am not liking Viva La Dirt League’s Daggerheart - Beast Feast campaign though. So much focus on ingredients and trade and cooking. I think characters are more fun.

    • blueduck@piefed.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      11 days ago

      I played so much VtM and werewolf in high school and college. It was way better than 3.5. I even liked playing a human mortal vs vampires. Tricky to do it right, but I could hold my own

      • skulblaka@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        10 days ago

        VtM absolutely requires a good group in order to have a good game, IMO. You can get by with a mediocre roleplaying group and still have fun playing something like D&D, or Pathfinder or LANCER, I think, but not so with WOD games. Roleplay IS the game.

        That kind of group is hard to find, in my experience, unless you manage to hunt down an existing VTM game and convince them to let you join.

        • blueduck@piefed.social
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          10 days ago

          100%. We had a dozen or so folks shifting in and out, but a core group of grey beards who would take responsibility for DMing