Fans were left in disbelief, with emotions of outrage and disappointment fluttering in, after finding out that NBC canceled Found after two seasons, along with a slew of other beloved shows that deserved a second chance.

The series stars Shanola Hampton as Gabi Mosley, a public relations and crisis management specialist at M&A, who helps locate missing people with her team, after getting kidnapped as a child by her English teacher, Hugh “Sir” Evans, played by 90210 alum Mark-Paul Gosselaar. In flashback scenes, fans see the dynamic between Gabi and Sir unfold, as it’s revealed she imprisoned him in her basement as payback, with season 2 trailing his movements following his escape and further plans for Gabi.