Here is the proposed addition for the ToU that @Gusted and I agreed on post-assembly for the upcoming membership vote. 🙏
The discussion for this proposal is available for Codeberg e. V. members in the forum: https://forum.codeberg.org/d/139-resolutions-for-assembly-on-codeberg-taking-a-stand-a...
Yeah, this makes sense. They won’t be able to kick every vibecoded project off, but it gives them a rule to point to when they do find and remove slop.
Some of the commenters on the Codeberg issue are expressing concerns about copyright status, but my main concern is security issues with these projects, which I have expressed before. Somebody vibecoded a script to sort files? I don’t really care.
Someone vibecoded a network facing application, shipping a docker container, and is trying to encourage people to deploy it? If I investigate, and see the bad security practices common to vibecoding, I wouldn’t want to be providing that for people to download. Even though I’m technically not responsible for it, it just doesn’t feel right to host something that could explode later. I would want to be able to take it down, and having a rule to point to prevents complaints when Codeberg does so.
Yeah, this makes sense. They won’t be able to kick every vibecoded project off, but it gives them a rule to point to when they do find and remove slop.
Some of the commenters on the Codeberg issue are expressing concerns about copyright status, but my main concern is security issues with these projects, which I have expressed before. Somebody vibecoded a script to sort files? I don’t really care.
Someone vibecoded a network facing application, shipping a docker container, and is trying to encourage people to deploy it? If I investigate, and see the bad security practices common to vibecoding, I wouldn’t want to be providing that for people to download. Even though I’m technically not responsible for it, it just doesn’t feel right to host something that could explode later. I would want to be able to take it down, and having a rule to point to prevents complaints when Codeberg does so.